Thermoregulation in Insect
Bemd Heinrich
University
of Vermont
In insects, as in other animals, body temperature strongly affects the rate of energy expenditure, the rate at which food can be located and harvested, growth, the facility with which mates can be acquired and predators avoided, and sometimes also the susceptibility to disease organisms. Thermoregulation refers to the ability to regulate that body temperature which best serves survival and reproduction, and it encompasses numerous conflicting constraints and selective pressures. In insects, major considerations involve body mass and access to either external or internal heat. Thermoregulation operates through behavior, physiology, and morphology. For the most part, insects are too small to be able to appreciably elevate, or regulate, their body temperature by internal heat production, although some are large enough and that, coupled with their high flight metabolism, could easily cause them to overheat. In numerous insects, elaborate mechanisms of thermoregulation have evolved both for heating and for cooling the body that possibly rival those of the typically endothermic vertebrates.
Insects arose on earth at least 350 mya in the Devonian Period of the Paleozoic Era. Little is known about the earliest forms, except that originally they must have been crawlers, not flyers, and their bodies assumed approximately the temperature of the immediate surroundings to which they adapted. This holds true even when the immediate surroundings are quite frigid. The adult form of a flightless midge (Diamesa sp.) walks on glacier ice even when its body temperature is chilled to — 16°C. It is so sensitive to heat that, when taken from its natural environment and held in one’s hand, it is killed by the warmth of one’s skin. However, there are insects that maintain quite specific and high body temperatures. Some species of sphinx moths, for example, have thick insulating fur and normally maintain a thoracic temperature near 46°C during flight over a wide range of ambient temperatures. To these moths, our own normal body temperature of 37°C is almost cool. An insect’s head and abdominal temperatures are for the most part unregulated.
In the
same way that the motor heats up when a car burns fuel, heat is released as an
inevitable by-product of cellular metabolism whenever muscle contracts. Close
to 94% of the energy expended by muscles during contraction is degraded to
heat, while approximately 6% appears as mechanical force on the wings. Insect
flight is one of the most energetically demanding activities known, and thus
most insects produce more heat per unit muscle mass when they fly than almost
any organism on earth. Most insects exist under conditions somewhere in between
the cold-blooded crawler and the hot- blooded flyer, but these extremes show us
what is possible, and they thus offer us a remarkable window into thermal
adaptation from an evolutionary perspective.
The ability
of birds and mammals to regulate body temperature at one set point,
specifically 37—4l°C, has long been considered proof of sophistication and
phylogenetic advancement relative to animals whose body temperature varies
with that of their environment. Deviation of body temperature from the set
point of 37—4l°C is, in birds and mammals, often associated with illness and
was once thought to be caused by a failure of the thermoregulatory system. We
now know that both increases and decreases in body temperature can be and often
are adaptive responses. Both responses are often sophisticated physiological
mechanisms that involve more thermoregulation rather than less, albeit the
body is kept at a more appropriate temperature for specific conditions.
Small
insects have much lower body temperatures in flight than large insects, not
because they produce less heat—in fact, they may have higher rates of
heat production than larger insects, but because they have much greater
conductance because of their large relative surface area. In bees, for example,
only the large species heat up in flight and generate an appreciable elevation
of body temperature even though metabolic cost of flight per unit weight
declines approximately 230% for a 10-fold increase in mass. A mosquito in
flight maintains only a tiny (<1 a="" ambient="" amounts="" and="" between="" blow="" despite="" fly="" gradient="" heat="" i="" of="" prodigious="" production.="" temperature="" thoracic="">(Calliphora
vicia)1>
may heat up 5°C, and a honey bee heats up its thorax about 15°C.
Having a much larger thorax, and hence a smaller relative surface area, means
that the internally generated heat during flight is not lost by convection at
the same rate that it is produced until a much higher temperature gradient has
been generated.
Large
insects—those that inevitably generate a high body temperature during
continuous flight—must be biochemically adapted to operate their flight muscles
at the high temperatures experienced. Temperature is important for mechanical
efficiency; at low muscle temperature there is partial overlap in contractions
of the up- and downstroke muscles, the
dorsoventral
and dorsal longitudinal muscles; the two sets of muscles then work against each
other rather than working to move the wings.
Numerous
other moths—such as most microlepidoptera and geometrids (inchworms) and some
ctenuchids and arctiids—are small or weak flyers that do not heat up but fly at
low air temperature. They fly at muscle temperatures much lower even than those
at which the large-bodied, small-winged (and hot-blooded) sphinx moths generate
zero power. Evolution has acted strongly to tailor the flight motor’s capacity
for maximum power output for much lower ranges of operating temperatures. For
example, the geometrid Operophtera bruceata can gain sufficient power to
fly at 0°C. (Nevertheless, its capacity to do so is only partially the result
of muscle physiology.)
The basis
for the evolution of differences between species arising from a common ancestor
is variation among individuals. Variation was present in the past, and for
many traits, variation is maintained even now. For example, in Colias (sulphur)
butterflies, the gene locus for phosphoglucose isomerase, one of the enzymes
involved in energy metabolism in these butterflies, changes in allele frequency
with season and habitat temperature. This suggests that natural selection is
occurring even over very short (that is, seasonal) time spans. The different
enzyme alleles have different thermal stabilities, and heterozygotes are
thought to have an advantage in an environment of rapidly fluctuating
temperatures inasmuch as the individuals heterozygotic for this locus fly over
a range of temperatures broader than that of individuals of other genotypes.
When a
seasonally changing temperature environment, which is the rule, can select for
heterozygosity, then one might expect that an environment of constantly high or
low temperature, which is the exception, should lead to the fixation of an
appropriate genotype. Hence, selection in terms of gene-frequency changes would
not normally be present for our inspection in more constant environments, in
which appropriate genotypes would already have been selected long ago to adapt
to the average temperature. The specific thoracic temperature that is
maintained by regulation is “chosen” by evolution probably because it is the
temperature most readily regulated for maximum activity over a range of
prevailing environmental conditions.
WARM-UP BY
SHIVERING
During his classic studies of honey bee
communication, Karl von Frisch noted that bees often interrupted flight for a
few minutes when they were returning to the hive heavily laden with nectar. He
presumed they stopped “to rest,” but we now know they were stopping to work: to
raise their thoracic temperature. They most likely stopped flight because it
was a cold day and they had cooled convectively. Bees are able to raise their
thoracic temperature by shivering, which can work their flight muscles harder
than flight itself does. Von Frisch could not have known any of this, because
shivering and thermoregulation by individual insects was unknown in the 1960s,
nor is shivering externally visible in bees even if one looks very closely.
Like the
maintenance of an elevated body temperature by internal heat production in
flight, physiological warm-up is found in all large, active flyers among the
dragonflies (Odonata), moths and butterflies (Lepidoptera), katydids
(Orthoptera), cicadas (Clypeorrhyncha or Homoptera), flies (Diptera), beetles
(Coleoptera), and wasps and bees (Hymenoptera). That is, it is found from some
of the earliest forms, the Odonata, to the most evolutionarily highly derived,
the Diptera, Coleoptera, and Hymenoptera. It is not found in the small and
therefore nonendothermic members of the same groups. Because no insects shiver
except those that then also heat up from flight metabolism, it seems reasonable
to conclude that the evolution of shivering behaviors is related to the
evolution of flight but is unrelated to the insect’s place on the phylogenic
tree.
During
preflight warm-up, there are synchronous contractions of groups of muscles
that normally contract alternately in flight. That is, the main wing-depressor
muscles, the dorsal longitudinal muscles, are excited simultaneously—in other
words, in synchrony—with the dorsoventral wing elevator muscles. The neural
activation pattern of thoracic flight muscles needs to be and is already very
labile for flight control, and to add shivering when flight behavior has
already evolved is probably a very minor evolutionary step. Physiological warmup
in its most basic form is like the idling of an engine; the engine “evolved” to
propel the car, not to warm it up. Once present, the heat-producing flight
muscle system required only a slight modification of neuronal activation
patterns and, in the more sophisticated models, also the addition of the biological
equivalent of a clutch—a mechanism to disengage the wings in the same way that
an automotive clutch disengages the car’s wheels. Some insects, such as
dragonflies and moths, do have visible external wing vibrations that were
originally called “wing whirring,” these were once thought to pump air into the
animal before the true function was elucidated.
The zenith
of the shivering response of any hot-blooded animal (vertebrate as well as
invertebrate) belongs to some bees. Honey bees and bumble bees have a
physiological sophistication either not existing or not yet observed in other
insects, and they exploit shivering behavior to an unprecedented extent and in
a variety of ways. Like flies and beetles, bees are “myogenic” flyers in which
the wing-beat cycle runs in part on automatic; as the downstroke muscles
contract they stretch the upstroke muscles. This stretching by itself
causes the upstroke muscles to contract. The downstroke of the wing therefore
automatically causes the upstroke muscles to contract and vice versa, in a
repeating cycle that is sparked by neural commands that are at a much lower
frequency than the wing beats and are no longer specific to a single wing beat.
(This system permits some of the smallest insects, such as midges, to achieve
the unprecedented coordination required for wing-stroke cycles of over 1000
beats per second.) But the stretching of opposing muscle groups that maintains
the myogenic contraction cycle can occur only if the wings are actually
beating—namely,
during
flight. When the wings are not in use, as when they are folded back dorsally
and the clutch-like wing hinge is engaged, then the muscle groups are in near
tetanus. That is the reason for the bees’ shivering.
Very
vigorous shivering in bees is physically dampened even more by yet another
mechanism. One of the two sets of opposite- acting muscles is activated (and
hence contracted) slightly more than the other. Because the opposing muscles
act like weights forcing down each side of a seesaw, the added force on one set
of muscles prevents the “seesaw” from working (and the wings from “vibrating”
back and forth).
WARM-UP BY
BASKING
Like
warm-up by shivering, warm-up by basking occurs in all major orders of insects
that have fast flyers large enough to heat up from their flight metabolism. In
its simplest form, behavioral warm-up is merely heat-seeking. A basking insect
usually takes specific postures that simultaneously maximize solar input and
minimize convective heat loss. Heat input is maximized by exposing the maximum
surface area to the sun, while convective heat loss is minimized by using body
parts (such as the spread wings) as baffles to retard air movement around the
body. Orienting the body parallel to the air stream (as a wingless insect might
do) would reduce the effect of convective cooling, but orienting the body
perpendicular to the sun’s rays to facilitate heating should take precedence,
because no heat loss can be minimized until heat is first gained. Grasshoppers,
beetles, and flies use these basking methods. For some dragonflies and
butterflies the wings are especially important during warm-up in their role of
reducing convective cooling.
Behaviorally
distinct types of basking have been described in butterflies, although some
(tropical) butterflies do not bask at all. In one type, called “lateral
basking,” the butterfly closes its wings dorsally and then tilts to present
either the right or the left wing and body surface to the sun. The lower
portions of the wings wrap around the body and touch it, and warming the lower
wing portions in sunshine then causes heat to be conducted directly through
them and into the body.
Many
species of small-bodied butterflies, primarily pierids and some lycaenids
(which commonly fly in breezy mountain meadows) bask by opening their wings
partially in a V so that the body is directly available to the sun’s rays at
the bottom of the V. The wings then serve as convection baffles to reduce
cooling in the breezy environment. “Dorsal baskers” hug a solid substrate, such
as the ground, and pull their wings down around them. They thereby expose the
dorsal body surface to the sun while simultaneously capturing heat from the
sun- heated substrate.
HEAT LOSS
MECHANISMS
Insects
near the size of a honey bee (approximately 200 mg) or larger may experience
body temperatures during forced flight exercise that are potentially lethal to
them. Alternately,
metabolic
heating may inhibit continuous flight at relatively modest ambient thermal
conditions (of air temperature and solar radiation), unless one or more of the
following mechanisms for heat loss are activated.
Harnessing
Convection
The rate
of convective heat loss from a body is determined by the conductance of the
body, i.e., its intrinsic rate of heat loss (which is a function of body size,
shape, and insulation). Conductance, in turn, is a function of the wind speed
(a hot body cools more quickly in wind than in still air— meteorologists call
this the “wind-chill factor”). However, no convective heat loss is possible,
regardless of conductance, if body and ambient temperature are equal, and at
any one conductance and wind speed the amount of heat loss is directly
proportional to the temperature difference between the body and the ambient
surroundings.
Small
insects that are endothermic in flight are sufficiently air-cooled such that
they almost never reach the potentially dangerous high-temperature ceiling of
near 45°C that is common to most animal tissues at normal atmospheric
pressures. These small insects thus have no need of a specialized cooling
system: they lose sufficient heat passively. Theoretically, larger insects
could cool themselves by increasing flight speed and thus increasing convective
heat loss, but flying faster would generally increase metabolic heat
production, which would cancel out the increased heat loss, unless the
internally generated heat is redistributed.
Heat
Radiators
A radiator
is a device that increases the surface area of a body or object so that more
heat can be transmitted to the surrounding environment by convection. In some
radiators, a fluid with a high heat capacity (like water, blood, or other
liquid) circulates by means of a pump and transfers heat from its source to the
radiator site for the heat loss. That is how a car engine is cooled.
Radiators
are utilized by many large insects from the very diverse orders Lepidoptera,
Odonata, Dipera, and Hymenoptera. The animals have a fluid-transfer cooling
mechanism that dissipates heat through an abdominal radiator, while small
members of the same groups that are not strong or continuous flyers lack the
heat-transfer response. When we humans exercise in the heat, blood is pumped to
the skin or extremities to facilitate heat loss, but this is done at the
expense of pumping blood and oxygen to the muscles instead. Therefore, work
capacity is compromised. Insects, on the other hand, do not need to compromise
aerobic work capacity at higher air temperatures because of thermoregulation.
In insects, the total separation of respiratory and heat-transfer functions
makes it possible for them to continue working, even when the fluid flow is
interrupted.
The
“radiator tube” that conducts the hemolymph to the abdominal heat radiator in
insects also serves as a pump,
which
operates by peristaltic contractions along its entire length. Although sphinx
moths in whom surgery has rendered this “heart” inoperative (by tying it shut)
can still fly until reaching near-lethal thoracic temperatures, removal of
their insulating layer of thoracic scales makes continuous flight again
possible.
Evaporative
Cooling
One of the
extraordinary examples of an evaporative cooling mechanism specifically for
thermoregulation is that found in the workers of honey bees, Apis mellijera,
and yellowjackets, Vespula spp. These insects use the head as a
radiator, but they do so with a difference. Nectar-gathering honey bees
normally fly with flight-motor temperatures near 15°C above air temperature.
They are capable of the astounding feat of flying even at ambient temperatures
near 45°C while maintaining the thorax at the same or only slightly lower
temperature. They do so by regurgitating nectar from the honeycrop, and while
the nectar is held on the mouthparts and the head, water evaporates from it.
Because of the physical contact between the head and the thorax,
thermoregulation of one effectively results in thermoregulation of the other.
Thus, the head is cooled by evaporation of water until there is a large temperature
difference between the head and the metabolically heated thorax, at which point
heat from the thorax follows the temperature gradient and is transmitted to the
head. Head temperature is actively regulated, with thoracic temperature passively
following, because artificial heating of the thorax alone does not result in
the heat-dissipation response so long as head temperature remains low. However,
artificial heating of the head (as with a narrow beam of light from a heat
lamp) almost immediately results in nectar regurgitation and evaporative
cooling, even while thoracic temperature is still (momentarily) low.
Some
insects cool evaporatively from the back. In the hot Australian deserts, the
larvae of the sawfly Perga dorsalis, in response to solar heat stress,
first raise their abdomen to the sun to shade the body and to increase
convective heat loss. In an emergency, when this response is insufficient, they
also emit rectal fluid and spread it over their ventral surface to cool
themselves evaporatively.
Diceroprocta
apache of the Sonoran desert of the southwestern
United States employs a third evaporative cooling mechanism, this one analogous
to sweating. These cicadas are plant-sap feeders, and despite living in a dry
environment, they have access to a large fluid supply by inserting their
sucking mouthparts into the xylem of deep-rooted shrubs, such as mesquite. They
thus indirectly tap water from deep underground stores. Cicadas sing when
ambient temperatures in the shade reach 40°C, and the repetitive contractions
of their tymbal muscles result in internal heat production that adds to the
already considerable external heat load.
Body temperature during this exercise in
the heat is reduced to tolerable levels by evaporative cooling from fluid shed through
large pores distributed over their dorsal body surfaces. The release of this
fluid, and the consequent evaporative cooling, occurs only in response to very
high body temperature. Most insects, especially those of desert environments,
are instead highly resistant to water loss when alive, and upon death, there
results an immediate increase in water loss as the spiracles are no
longer actively maintained shut. Killing of the cicada, in contrast,
immediately stops the sweating response, therefore showing that it is under
metabolic control. The cooling response is mediated, ironically enough, by
aspirin-like substances produced in their bodies in response to heat stress.
MORPHOLOGY
AND THERMOREGULATION
Aside from
physiology, various aspects of insects’ morphology come into play in their
thermoregulating responses.
Insulation
Many
hot-blooded insects that regulate their body temperature have, like their
endothermic vertebrate counterparts, bodies wholly or at least partially
covered with insulation. One type of insulation is derived from air sacs.
Insects already have air sacs used for breathing, and still air is, next to a
vacuum, the best possible insulator. Many insects of various orders have air
sacs between the thorax and the abdomen that greatly retard the leakage of heat
into the abdomen. But large-bodied dragonflies have gone one step further:
their air sacs surround the thoracic flight motor. The other two types of
insulation are derived from exterior cuticular structures.
Lepidopterans
are covered with a layer of thin overlapping scales, which are especially
noticeable in coloring the wings. Rather than remaining flat and colorful for
visual signaling as in butterflies, they have become long and thin to form a
thick insulating body (thoracic) pile or fur coat in many moths. This coating
of pile is so effective as insulation it more than halves the rate of heat
loss, or doubles the temperature excess, hence permitting flight at much lower
air temperatures. Endothermic insects with pile now fly in many northern areas
and at times of the year at which they would otherwise be excluded. Conversely,
insects from tropical environments have no or only sparse pile covering.
A covering
of setae, small hair-like projections from the cuticle, is the third source of
insect insulation. Setae have various functions and numerous independent
evolutionary origins. Within the Hymenoptera, only the northernmost large bees,
the bumble bees, have a heavily insulated flight motor. However, even honey
bees have a layer of short insulating pile on the thorax, which aids them on
cool mornings and at high elevations. Bees inhabiting the tropics and hot
deserts do not have a covering of pile dense enough to provide appreciable
insulation. But even tropical bees cannot get along totally without setae,
because they use these projections to trap pollen from flowers. Some wasps, in
contrast, live in the same northern areas that bumble bees do,
but they
do not rely on pollen for protein. Instead, many are predators on fast-flying
insects, and they are glabrous. Perhaps an advantage of fuel economy in flight,
or perhaps the necessity for fast flight, has assumed more importance than
drag-inducing insulation for thermoregulatory control.
Color
In a few
instances, an insect’s color has a functional significance in thermal balance
during basking. For example, lateral- basking sulphur butterflies (Colias
spp., usually yellow or white) found in cool environments (such as mountaintops
or high latitudes) or seasons (early spring) tend to have dark wing undersides.
These darker individuals are able to heat up the thorax slightly faster than
lighter congeners, which buys them additional flight time when basking is
needed to prepare for flight.
Although
color can have a slight thermal advantage, it is more often subservient to
other needs, such as the need to evade predators. Not surprisingly, insects
that inhabit open ground often match their background in color and thus are
highly camouflaged.
A beetle
walking on hot desert sand might experience temperatures that could kill it in
a minute or less. Just a few millimeters above the ground, however, the hot,
ground- hugging air layer is disrupted and mixed with cooler air from above. If
we were shrunk to Lilliputian size and forced to live where a few millimeters’
difference in elevation could mean the difference between life and death, we
would find some way to lift ourselves above the searing heat. Numerous ground-
dwelling beetles living on hot sands do just that. Tiger beetles (Cicindelidae)
begin to stand tall when sand temperatures exceed 40°C. Aside from extending
their jointed legs to stand taller, some beetles, like Stenocara phalangium
(Tenebrionidae) from the Namib Desert of southern Africa, have evolved very
long stilt-like legs that allow them to avoid overheating by both avoiding the
heat at ground level and losing some of the solar heat by convection through
fast running.
Another
option is to use one body part to shade another. For example, some beetles
reduce their absorption of external heat from direct solar radiation by having
an air space beneath the elytra that insulates the abdomen from direct solar
radiation.
At low air
temperatures when the abdomen is cool, the flight motor could cool
precipitously if the hemolymph carried heat away from the thorax to be
dissipated from the abdomen. Two mechanisms, however, normally prevent this
potential problem of thoracic cooling. The first is a temporary reduction or
elimination of the circulation: to retard heat loss.
Another
mechanism, one more subtle than cardiac arrest, helps some insects prevent heat
leakage from thorax to abdomen. Proof of that is seen in honey bee workers and
Cuculliinae winter moths, which never show appreciable increases in abdominal
temperature, even as the flight motor stays hot. An examination of their
circulatory anatomy explains the mystery: they harness countercurrent heat
transfer.
A
countercurrent implies two separate currents flowing next to each other but in
opposite directions, as through the petiole between thorax and abdomen in
insects. If the fluid in one current is of a higher temperature than that of
the other, then heat (which is not confined by the vessel walls) will passively
flow “downhill,” from high to low temperature, across these walls. Thus, if the
hot blood leaving the thorax flows around the vessel in close proximity to cool
blood entering it from the abdomen, as in most bees, then heat exchange is
inevitable. At least some of the heat from the thorax will be recycled back
into the thorax because the incoming blood is heated by the outgoing blood. In
honey bees and winter moths, countercurrent heat exchange is greatly enhanced
by prolonging the area for that potential heat exchange to occur, as the aorta
in the petiole is lengthened and (in honey bees) convoluted into loops.
Bumble
bees and northern vespine wasps have a very much different and seemingly less
efficient countercurrent heat exchange circulatory anatomy than honey bees and
winter moths (Fig. 1). This situation may seem counterintuitive because they
live in cold climates, some species even inhabiting the High Arctic. They might
thus be expected to have even better countercurrent heat exchangers than honey
bees, which are of temperate and tropical origin. Instead of
Aorta
Insulation
■—Air sacs —
Ventral diaphragm
FIGURE 1 Anatomy of a bumble bee (Bombus) relevant to thermoregulation.
The thorax is insulated with pile that reduces the rate of convective heat
loss. The ventor of the abdomen is lightly insulated or uninsulated when the
bee presses her abdomen onto brood to be heated. Hemolymph (blood) is pumped
anteriorly by the heart, from the abdomen into the thorax. When dissipating
heat from the working muscles in the thorax, the blood enters the aorta from the
heart in pulses. Each pulse of cool blood from the abdominal heart into the
thoracic aorta alternates with a pulse of warm blood entering the abdomen to
the thermal window. In this way, countercurrent heat flow (into blood returning
to the thorax) is minimized and heat flow (into the abdomen) is maximized.
[Reproduced, by permission of Oxford University Press, from B. Heinrich,
(1976),/. Exp. Biol. 64, 561-585.]
having
more loops for countercurrent heat exchange, they have none! Nevertheless,
their anatomy can also be understood in terms of thermal strategy, but as it
relates to their social system.
Bumble bee
and wasp queens start their colonies very early in the spring; each new queen
attempts this task alone, as an individual. To this individual bee or wasp,
time is of the essence, for she must complete the whole colony cycle within a
single growing season. A queens first priority, then, is to rear a group of
helpers. Temperatures when and where she builds her nest may be near 0°C, and
if the brood were left at that temperature it might take years for them to
develop to adults—provided they could withstand the freezing temperature. Even
in the High Arctic, however, the queens of Bombus polaris can produce a
batch of workers in about 2 weeks, as can other bumble bees and Vespula
wasps. Both bees and wasps accomplish these feats by incubating the brood from
the egg to the pupal stage. The queens perch upon their brood clump—consisting
of eggs, larvae, and/or pupae—and they press their abdomen upon the brood, much
as a hen incubates her eggs with her belly. Only the abdomen provides a smooth
surface for contact, but only the thorax produces heat by way of intense
shivering by the flight muscles. No incubation, and hence social life, would be
possible for these insects in a cold environment if, like honey bees, they were
incapable of transferring heat from the source of its production into the
abdomen that provides the smooth tight contact with the brood.
The bumble
bees aorta is long enough to permit moderate heat exchange and hence retention
of heat in the thorax, but it is short and straight enough so that a
physiological mechanism can be activated that shunts the fluid and heat
through, effectively eliminating countercurrent heat exchange.
Countercurrent
heat exchangers in vertebrate animals can be bypassed by rerouting the blood
into an alternate (generally external) channel. That is why our own veins seem
to pop out when we are active in the heat. Such rerouting of the blood from
internal to external channels is not possible, however, in insects with open
circulatory systems lacking veins and capillaries. Instead, in bumble bees
there is a physiological solution for heat loss in the presence of a
countercurrent heat exchange anatomy that serves the same purpose as an
alternate blood channel. In the bumble bee, this consists of an alternating-current
flow of blood. To shunt heat past the heat exchanger and into the abdomen, the
bee lifts a small valve that allows a pulse of warm blood to enter the abdomen,
and in the fraction of a second after the warm blood enters the abdomen, she
then squirts a bolus of cool blood into the thorax. And so it goes back and
forth, hot and cold pulses of hemolymph passing alternately through the heat
exchange area in the bee s waist. The essential point is that although the
blood is not rerouted into a different channel, it is instead temporarily
“chopped” into alternating pulses in the same channels. This is the opposite of
countercurrent flow because instead of recovering heat from the thorax, the
system acts to remove it, in this case into the abdomen.
The pumping of hemolymph by the heart
and the ventral diaphragm is also aided by in—out pumping movements of the whole
abdomen, which otherwise function only for moving gas in and out of the thorax;
the in—out telescoping movements of the abdomen are synchronous with the heart
beats and the ventral diaphragm beats, and they cause pressure changes that
facilitate hemolymph flow in precise alternating currents.
THERMAL
ARMS RACES Against Predators
On a
summer day in the Sahara Desert in Algeria, as the sun rises and begins to heat
the sands that have been cold at night, an abundance of insect life is forced
to retreat to cool underground refuge. Those unfortunate ones caught out in
the heat become disoriented and, moving frantically, they heat up even more,
then they die. The sun keeps rising, and sand temperatures begin to exceed
46°C. The desert lizards, Accanthodactylus dumerili, continue to hunt the
incapacitated prey and any ants they can find. But they now dash quickly across
the sand, and when they stop and stand, they alternately lift their feet to
prevent burning them. Meanwhile, long-legged silver ants, Cataglyphis
bombycina, avoid the lizards by remaining in their burrows under the sand.
However, they are poised to leave, waiting for the sand temperatures to heat up
even more, until it reaches about 60°C, when the temperature of the air at ant
height is about 46.5°C. Temperature “testers” among them lurk at the nest
entrance. At the right moment, they signal the time to come out by releasing
pheromones from their mandibular secretions. The rest of the colony then rushes
out into the field to forage safely, until they too must retire back to their
underground shelters—when they experience air temperatures of 53.6°C, which is
just a fraction of a degree below their thermal death point.
In the
southwestern deserts of the United States near Phoenix, Arizona, the desert or
Apache cicada, D. apache, also engages in a thermal arms race against
vertebrate predators. These cicadas are active at the hottest time of the year,
and even then they wait until the high midday temperatures of 44°C (in the
shade) near noon to be most active, when the cicada- killing wasps and birds
are forced to retire from the heat.
In the
deserts of southern California, the grasshopper Trimerotropis pallidipennis
endures heat rather than regulating heat loss like the sweating cicada. By
blending in with the background of the desert floor, it hides to escape bird
and lizard predators. Normally grasshoppers that inhabit the ground stilt high
above that substrate when it becomes heated to very high temperatures in
sunshine. But to remain camouflaged it is imperative for T. pallidipennis
to crouch down onto the searing hot ground. When that ground heats to near 60°C
in sunshine, the duration of time that a grasshopper can remain hidden is
limited by how high a body temperature it can tolerate. T. pallidipennis
has evolved to tolerate the extraordinary high body temperature of 50°C and can
thus escape into the sanctuary of sunlight, where a predator such as a lizard
or bird cannot hunt.
It is
probably rare that insects escape predators by seeking out low temperatures.
Possibly the best candidates are the Cuculli- inae, a subfamily of the
generally endothermic Noctuidae or owlet moths. The Cuculliinae are a northern
circumpolar group of moths, and in northern New England they may fly during any
month of the winter when temperatures reach 0—10°C and when most of their bat
and bird predators have left. During flight, cuculliinines have flight-motor
temperatures near 30—35°C, as do other moths of their size and wing loading.
Unlike all other moths, however, the cuculliinines can begin to shiver at the
extraordinarily low muscle temperature of 0°C, and they continue shivering to
warm up all the way to 35°C.
The giant
hornets, Vespa mandarinia, attack honey bee colonies. During a typical
giant hornet attack, a lone hornet forager first captures bees at the periphery
of the bees’ nest. After several successful foraging trips to the beehive, the
hornet deposits a marking pheromone at the hive entrance from the van der Vecht
gland at the tip of the abdomen. This pheromone attracts other hornets from the
home nest, and then the slaughter phase of the hornet attack begins: 30,000
bees can be killed in 3 h by a group of 30 to 40 hornets. Subsequently the
hornets may occupy the hive itself, and then they carry off the bees’ larvae
and pupae to feed to their own young.
The above
happens when hornets attack colonies of the introduced European honey bee, A.
melUfera, but the Japanese honey bee, A. cerana, has evolved an
effective counterstrategy to the hornets’ mass invasion. With the latter,
those unfortunate hornets that are recruited by the pheromone and then try to
enter the hive are met and killed by heat as hundreds of bees envelop each wasp
into a tight ball. The interior of these bee balls quickly rises to 47°C,
killing the hornet but not the bees, whose upper lethal temperature is 48 to
50°C.
Against
Competitors
Contest
competition or fighting over food is rare in insects, but at least two species
of African dung beetles, Scarabaeus laevistriatus and Kheper
nigroaeneus, engage in combat over dung balls that they make to feed on
and/or to serve as sexual attractants. An elevated thoracic temperature plays a
crucial role in these contests on the ground. The more a beetle shivers to keep
warm (with its flight muscles), the higher the temperature of the leg muscles
adjacent to the flight muscles in the thorax and the faster its legs can move
and construct the dung into balls and roll it away. Endothermy thus aids in the
scramble competition for food, and it reduces the duration of exposure to
predators. Additionally, hot beetles have the edge in contest competitions over
dung balls made by other beetles; in fights over dung balls, hot beetles almost
invariably defeat cooler ones, often despite a large size disadvantage.
Mate
Competition
For large insects, endothermic heat
production is a requisite for flight, and it is during flight that other
activities, including foraging, oviposition, and predator escape, as opportunity
and necessity dictate, may occur. Hence, to find a direct effect of body
temperature on mating success specifically, one must examine a mating behavior
that is not already tightly linked with some other temperature-dependent
activity. Singing in some species is a good candidate. Singing is one activity
that serves only for mate attraction, and in katydids and cidadas only males
sing and the females remain silent. The vigor of this singing activity is
associated with and dependent on thermoregulation. Katydids, Neoconocephalus
robustus, warm up for their ear-shattering mating concerts by shivering,
bringing flight-muscle temperatures above 30°C. Males of the Malaysian green
bush cricket, Hexacentrus unicolor, sing from dusk until well into the
night, and before they sing, they prepare themselves by shivering to achieve
thoracic temperatures near 37°C. At thoracic temperatures of 37 to 38°C, the
males are able to achieve the extraordinarily fast wing movements of up to about
400 vibrations per second.
The
dragonfly Libellula pulchella demonstrates both the importance of body
temperature for mating success and the trade-offs required for maximizing power
output as an insect matures. The young, nonreproductive adults of this species
are sit-and-wait predators that typically fly with relatively low thoracic
temperature. Their flight-muscle performance does not peak at any one
temperature; instead, performance is uniformly spread over a wide range of low
thoracic temperatures. In contrast, sexually mature males engage in nearly
continuous flight in intense territorial contests. At such times, they generate
a very high thoracic temperature, and they regulate that thoracic temperature
precisely and within only 2.5°C from their upper lethal temperature. Thus,
muscle performance of the sexually mature males is narrowly specialized
relative to that of young adults that do not engage in strenuous battle.
SOCIAL
THERMOREGULATION
Many of
the social insects regulate the temperature of their nests in coordinated
behavioral and physiological responses involving the adult nest inhabitants.
Nest temperature regulation functions primarily to maintain activity and to
keep the otherwise thermally labile larvae at the proper temperature for rapid
growth. Thermoregulation allows social insects to rapidly build up large nest
populations and to inhabit environments where they could not otherwise exist.
Nest Site
One of the
first requirements for effective nest temperature regulation is the choice of
an appropriate nest site. Typically, northern ants nest in the open, often
under solar-heated rocks, or they make solar-heated mounds; many termites also
nest to maximize exposure to solar radiation. Honey bees, that live in northern
temperate climates require enclosed nest sites such as tree cavities, whereas a
variety of other more tropical bees have open and exposed nests.
Nest
Construction
Northern
vespine wasps enclose their nests in multiple layers of paper that insulate the
nest contents. Some termites and ants construct nests so located and
constructed as to maximize solar heating in the morning and evening and to
minimize overheating at noon. Nests may be constructed so that air circulation
and heat transfer are enhanced for thermoregulation.
Behavior
and Physiology
Ants
regulate the temperature of their brood by carrying it to those parts of the
nest with suitable temperatures. Both honey bees and vespine wasps regulate the
temperature of the nest, especially near the brood. They fan to circulate air
and carry off heat when nest overheating is imminent, and if temperatures
continue to increase they carry in water and sprinkle it on the combs for
evaporative cooling results. At low temperatures, such as during winter and in
swarm clusters outside the hive, the bees crowd together tightly as air
temperatures drop, thereby trapping heat inside. As air temperatures rise, the
bees on the cluster start to disperse, the cluster loosens, and heat from the
interior is released. In hives containing both honeycomb and comb with brood,
the bees preferentially cluster around the brood. Brood temperature is
maintained near 36°C in hives that may be subjected to air temperatures as low
as —50°C and as high as 50°C, provided the bees have access to honey as an
energy source for heat production in the cold and to water for evaporative
cooling in the heat.